|
Developing a Utility
Water Conservation Program
STATE TRUSTEESHIP
The New Hampshire legislature has adopted policies and statutes which
set forth the concept that state government has a trustee responsibility
to ensure the wise use of our water resources. Although relatively
water rich, New Hampshire still needs to protect and conserve these resources
if we are to meet our obligations to both the environment and society in
the future.
UTILITY & CONSUMER RESPONSIBILITIES
This document provides information pertaining to actions that a water
utility can take to develop an overall water conservation program.
Fact sheet WD-WSEB-6-2 identifies what individual consumers can do to conserve
water. The Department of Environmental Services (DES) urges public
water systems to develop a balanced water conservation program that both
prevents waste and also makes wise and beneficial use of the water resources
so richly bestowed on New Hampshire. This document is intended as
a very basic introduction to the topic of water conservation. Other
references are given at the end of this document.
DEVELOPING THE GOALS OF THE UTILITY'S CONSERVATION PLAN
Before a utility can implement a conservation plan, it must determine
the goals of the plan and the needs which are being addressed. These
factors will guide policy development and implementation.
Public water systems serve many needs of society and produce a variety
of benefits. These include providing safe water for drinking purposes,
abundant water for producing goods
and services, irrigation water to beautify our public spaces and homes,
water for outdoor recreational opportunities such as swimming pools and
amusement parks, and water availability for fire protection. In the
past, these benefits have been taken for granted with little regard for
the impact of that water withdrawal on the environment. Often the
very low cost for water in the past has lead to its very inefficient use.
While satisfying the needs of water customers, we must be mindful of
the sometimes severe impact that water supply withdrawal has on the environment.
This often results in dewatering environmental habitats and drying up of
nearby residential wells. The goal of an effective water conservation
program should be to maintain the benefits cited above while not causing
damage to the environment.
WATER CONSERVATION CONCEPTS
There are at least three concepts that a utility can use in developing
its strategy for water conservation. They are:
Require the installation of water conserving plumbing devices
by customer.
Adopt billing policies that provide price incentives for conservation.
Develop educational programs to motivate users to conserve.
In many cases, the overall plan chosen by the water commissioners will
have components representative of all three of these concepts. The
advantages and disadvantages of each strategy are discussed briefly below.
A Device Based Strategy. Installation of "add
on" devices or replacement with new water fixtures that use water more
efficiently. Examples include water saving toilets or drip irrigation
systems. The advantage of such a device strategy is that the
water savings which are achieved, last forever. The drawback is that
devices have an initial capital cost, which often can be high and requires
the homeowner's participation. Entry into homes creates homeowner
concerns and is inconvenient when all adults work during the day.
A Price Incentive Strategy. Where the price of water is
generally low, water is undervalued relative to other basic costs, there
is little expectation that excessive usage will be constrained by a low
price or only a modest price increase. On the other hand, where water
rates are relatively high, that rate, or an increase in the rate, is a
substantial motivator to achieve conservation. In some situations
the conservation achieved by higher water rates diminishes with the passage
of time.
An Educational Strategy. Educating the users to the
importance of using water wisely. Education actions can have
little appreciable startup cost and thus can be easily instituted.
The limitation however, is that without a continuing emphasis on education,
which is staff intensive, the motivation to conserve often diminishes
with time.
IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY BY THE UTILITY
Begin with Larger Users
It is often wise to first identify all major water users served by
the system and estimate
he relative magnitude of use by each. The typical implementation
strategy would be to focus on
the larger users first. This could achieve the largest return
for the initial staff time invested in the conservation program.
In-home Usage - Strategy for Achieving Reductions.
Typical water use in a single family home is approximately 250 gallons
per day (gpd) for a family of four persons. Toilet use and water
used for personal hygiene are the largest in-home components. Historically,
this use has accounted for approximately 40 percent of overall interior
water use. Consumers typically find this is the easiest category
within which to reduce water consumption. See DES fact sheet WD-WSEB-6-2
concerning customers conservation.
In 1991-92 the federal government took a major conservation step by
requiring that all new toilets installed in the U.S. use not more than
1.6 gallons per flush. This is an approximate 50 percent reduction
from the previous industry average.
Exterior Usage - Strategy for Achieving Reductions
Exterior water use dramatically exceeds that of in-home use.
A typical 4-6 gallons per minute (gpm) lawn sprinkler will use as much
water in an hour as will be used otherwise within the home in an entire
day. Since usage in this category is so high, even a slight reduction
in outside water use typically exceeds the savings that could be expected
from a substantial reduction in any "in-home" water use category.
In addition, since exterior use occurs mostly during the summer, the benefits
from conservation are achieved when the water resource is typically under
the greatest withdrawal stress.
In water poor portions of the country, zoning and building codes
specify the type of allowable landscaping so as to reduce exterior demand
of exterior water use. The concept of drip irrigation probably holds
the greatest promise of reducing outside water demand without creating
a major negative impact. Other options include low-water tolerant
shrubs and mineral based (colored crushed stone) landscaping.
SOME CAUTIONS CONCERNING CONSERVATION
There are certain consequences of water conservation that need to be
addressed as part of the overall implementation strategy. Some are
noted below.
Revenue Loss. Since conservation reduces the volume
of water used, successful conservation will reduce a water system's revenue.
Consequently, water rates will need to be increased to maintain a balanced
budget. Although the rate (dollars per 1,000 gallons) will increase,
the overall amount of the water bill of an average customer that practices
conservation should not increase because they now use less water.
We suggest identifying this revenue consequence "up front" as part of the
promotion of the water conservation program.
Fixed Costs Remain. Most water utilities have high
fixed costs for example the building water storage tanks, installation
of water mains, and developing new water supply sources. Generally,
there is little cost saving realized when water production decreases other
than a slight lowering of electrical and chemical costs.
Loss of Resource Potential. With a reduction in overall
water use, the board of commissioners of a typical water system usually
defers purchasing the rights to new water resource areas. With the
passage of time many of these nearby, relatively low cost water resource
sites will be developed and thus lost forever. Securing new water
resource site(s) should be an integral part of a water conservation plan.
Effectiveness of Water Conservation Plans. Where
wasteful use of water has been dramatically reduced by an active water
conservation program, the future implementation of a summertime water ban
should not be expected to achieve as much a response as was achieved in
the past. Thus a utility must be more aware of the safe yield of
its supplies under drought conditions and be most vigilant to ensure that
supply capability always is substantially in excess of the customer's water
demand.
LEAK DETECTION AND WATERSHED MANAGEMENT
The water utility also has other major roles in a comprehensive water
conservation plan. Those rules include a comprehensive leak detection program
for the distribution system and carrying out proper watershed management
to maximize the safe yield of all sources. An effective leak
detection program and effective metering should achieve "unaccounted for
water use" under 10 percent of total production. Utilities must set
the right example in leak detection if they expect customers to follow.
FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
The DES has a number of more detailed documents which provide greater
detail concerning a water conservation program. These documents are
available for reference from the DES's Water Supply Engineering Bureau
office at 29 Hazen Drive, Concord. These documents are from industry
and other states. For a complete listing of all fact sheets please
request WD-WSEB-15-2. Drinking water fact sheets are available
through the DES web site at: http://www.des.state.nh.us
then select: publications, fact sheets, water division, water supply. 2/99
WATER CONSERVATION REFERENCES
American Water Works Association
6666 W. Quincy Ave
.
Denver, CO 80235
1-303-794-7711 |
State of Arizona, Dept. of Environmental Quality
3033 N. Central Ave
Pheonix, AZ 85012
1-602-207-2300 |
Northeast Rural Water Assoc.
6 Prim Rd.
P.O. Box 622
Colchester, VT 05446
1-802-660-4988 |
State of California
Dept. of Health Services
601 North 7th Street, PO Box 942732
Sacramento, CA 94234-7320
1-916-323-6111 |
|