|
Interpreting The Presence Of
Coliform Bacteria In Drinking Water
Determining the bacterial quality of drinking water is the single most
important water quality test. Why? Because one glass of water containing
just a few disease organisms can cause illness. When minimal exposure creates
an immediate health risk that factors is known as an acute health
risk. In contrast, a meaningful health risk from chemical contaminants
such as arsenic, radon, or benzene, to name only a few, requires a long
period of exposure, typically over many years.
The total coliform test is the basic yardstick for determining a water
supply's
biological quality. This test is performed frequently because of the risk
that disease causing organisms pose to health. The test is easy to perform,
inexpensive, and errs on the side of caution.
Total Coliform As An Indicator Organism
The organisms in the total coliform group
are called indicator organisms. That is, if present, they indicate that
there is a possibility, but not a certainty, that disease organisms
may also be present in the water. When absent there is a very low
probability of disease organisms being present in the water. The ability
of the total coliform test to reliably predict the bacterial safety of
water relative to the hundreds of possible diseases that might be present
is critical since it impossible, in a practical sense, to check separately
for every disease organism directly on a monthly or quarterly basis.
Recently however, public health experts
have recognized that certain protozoa which cause disease, such as giardia
and cryptosporidium, can be present in surface water even when the total
coliform test shows absence. Although an important exception, the total
coliform test remains the standard for determining the bacterial quality
of drinking water in the US and the world.
Members of the Total Coliform Family
There are a number of subgroups within
the overall coliform family as shown in the diagram on the right. The presence
of bacteria from each progressively smaller subgroup heightens the concern
that disease-causing organisms may be present in the water. These groups
and their relative risk implications are discussed below.
Total Coliform.
These organisms are very prolific in the soil and their presence does not
necessarily imply poor wastewater disposal or other sanitation based health
risks. The presence of only total coliform generally does not imply
an imminent health risk but does require an analysis of all water systems
facilities and their operation to determine how these organisms entered
the water system.
"Public notice"
to public water system users is required since a properly constructed and
properly maintained water system should not have total coliform present.
Fecal Coliform. This is a much smaller
group within the total coliform family. Fecal coliform generally originate
in the intestines of mammals. They have a relatively short life span compared
to more general coliforms. Their presence could be related to improper
disposal of sanitary waste. Immediate
"public
notice" to public water system users
is required due to the higher perceived risk of disease organisms also
being presence in water.
Escherichia Coli (e-coli). This
is a specific species (subgroup) within the coliform family. They originate
only in the intestines of animals and humans. Like fecal coliform they
have a relatively short life span compared to more general coliform. Their
presence indicates a strong likelihood that human or animal wastes are
entering the water system. Immediate
"public
notice" is required due to higher perceived
risk of disease organism also being presence in the water.
Non-Coliform.
Multiple tests can be used to
determine the presence of coliforms. The membrane filter test produces
a test results for non-coliform organisms in the water. This value has
importance in the two areas:
Invalidation of The Total ColiformTest
When the number of non-coliform
organisms is high, their presence may inhibit the growth of other more
important organisms in the total coliform family. That action will invalidate
that total coliform test.
Non-coliform As Indicator of Adequate Filtration
It is believed that the number
of non-coliform organisms in a well should be small. Thus when numbers
are high, there is concern that the water in the well is not being sufficiently
filtered. Reasons for a lack of adequate filtration include:
a. The well is not properly constructed;
or
b. The soil / rock is not properly filtering
the rainfall water that is percolating down from above.
See fact sheets WD-WSEB-1-2
through 1-6 for references for proper well construction.
For More Information
For more information concerning total coliforms
please call DES's Water Supply Engineering Bureau at (603) 271-3139 or
the DES laboratory at 603-271-3445. For more information concerning giardiasis
and cryptosporidium see fact sheets WD-WSEB-4-6 and 4-7 respectively.
For an overall listing of water supply
related fact sheets, please request WD-WSEB-15-2. We would appreciate your
suggestions concerning this fact sheet.
Drinking water fact sheets are available
through the DES web site at: http://www.des.state.nh.us/ws.htm
then select: publications, fact sheets, water division, water supply.
8/98
|