|
Taste and Odor in Drinking Water
Taste and odor (T/O), at objectionable levels, occur in approximately
10-15 percent of water wells in New Hampshire. Hydrogen sulfide odor (rotten
eggs) is reported most often. For information on hydrogen sulfide
please see the DES fact sheet WD-WSEB-3-16 entitled,
"Hydrogen Sulfide in Drinking Water." This fact sheet discusses T/O
contaminants other than hydrogen sulfide.
In groundwater supplies, the origin of T/O contaminants generally
cannot be determined. The principal causes of T/O are thought to
include:
| - |
Recharge of the well by water originating from wetland type areas. |
| - |
Chemical reactions between various minerals in soil or rock, possibly
enhanced by the actions of various natural occurring nonhazardous bacteria
in the soil. |
| - |
Manmade contaminants inadvertently entering the soil. |
In surface water, T/O problems typically are attributed to algae
and dissolved organic matter. T/O problems in surface water in New
Hampshire are generally rare. The most common T/O by-products are 2-methylisoborneol
and geosmin. The DES laboratory does not test for either of these
factors. The DES strongly cautions against the use of unfiltered,
undisinfected surface water for drinking purposes.
LABORATORY TESTING
The characterization of odor is often very difficult because T/O identification
generally is very subjective. The DES laboratory does not generally
characterize odors in drinking water samples. However, the laboratory
can test for particular elements or compounds thought to cause a
particular T/O condition.
If you desire to identify the compound(s) that are creating T/O you
should recognize that this will be a difficult process with a low likelihood
of success (other than for the compound hydrogen sulfide).
First, you will need to decide what contaminant(s) are believed to cause
the T/O. Then have the laboratory test for that factor(s).
If that factor is present at elevated levels, then that factor probably
contributes to the overall problem. If it is not present at meaningful
amounts, the hypothesis will need to be revised and laboratory tests processed
for these new compounds. Please see page 4 for some, but by no means
all, T/O causing compounds.
MANMADE CAUSES
Occasionally, T/O can indicate the presence of serious health related
contaminants such as those from industrial chemicals. These are often associated
with land uses such as landfills and industrial areas. In years past, these
chemicals were also associated with "mid-night dumping" in rural areas.
To determine the presence of these contaminants, very expensive laboratory
testing is typically required. Whether there is sufficient justification
for such testing would require an evaluation of the area nearby and uphill
of your well.
HEALTH SIGNIFICANCE
Until the factor(s) creating the T/O is identified, an assessment of
health significance of T/O can not be made.
When a well shows a noticeable and rapid change in T/O characteristics,
after a long history (at least two-three years) of stable quality, the
safety of the water source should be questioned and laboratory testing
performed. Some wells have seasonal variation in T/O characteristics.
If occurring every year, these would likely imply a condition of natural
origin with lower risk.
TREATMENT
T/O characteristics generally can be removed from drinking water.
The most common treatment options are listed below.
Aeration: In this process, large volumes of air are blown
through the water. The T/O factors volatize into the air bubbles.
This air is vented to the outside of your home similar to the way moist,
lint-laden air vents from a clothes dryer.
An important requirement of this method is the need to have clean air,
free of dust, mosquitoes, etc. The principal disadvantage of aeration
is the possibility of creating bacterial growth in the treated water and
the high cost of the aeration equipment. See fact sheet WD-WSEB-2-23.
Aeration is also beneficial in removing radon gas and carbon dioxide (CO2
). CO2 can make water acidic, thus dissolving lead and
copper from your plumbing. See fact sheet WD-WSEB-3-4.
Oxidation: In this method, an oxygen-like chemical (such
as oxygen, potassium permanganate, ozone or chlorine) is added to the water.
The oxygen-like chemical reacts with the odor compounds and is chemically
destroyed. One variation on this process uses a venturi nozzle to
add small amounts of ordinary air to the water. Oxygen in the air reacts
with the contaminants and the remaining air is removed from the water by
an air relief valve. This system generally offers good service at low cost.
Adsorption: In this process, the raw water is passed through
activated carbon. The carbon can be granular or a 'pressed block.'
The T/O components adsorb (stick) to the interior surface of the carbon
particles as the water passes through. Activated carbon may not fully
remove certain T/O factors. Further, where radionuclides are high,
adsorption of radon, uranium, radium and others radionuclides may create
a low level radionuclide waste and/or a source of radiation within the
home.
CHOOSING THE TREATMENT PROCESS
T/O treatment can be somewhat experimental. Typically one method will
be tried to see if that method works for your particular T/O type. If not,
another method from those above will be tried. Experienced water treatment
professionals will know which option to try first.
Where the T/O characterization is unusual, a so-called 'pilot-size treatment
process" could be tried. This approach allows the treatability of
the T/O to be determined easily on a small scale device before major effort
and expense is committed to installing the full size treatment device.
Often the laboratory will not be able to identify any of the contaminant(s)
which likely would cause T/O. In such cases a treatment device, often
activated carbon, will be installed at least at the kitchen sink with the
hope of lowering the concentration of the unknown contaminant. In such
situations the water is not necessarily thought of as pure, but the treatment
is seen as improving an unacceptable poor situation.
T/O REFERENCES
Shown on the next page are common T/O characterizations and the contaminants
that may cause them. The principal reference for this list is:
Taste and Odor in Drinking Water, American Water Works Research Foundation
Report ISN 0-89867-864-1, 1996
FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
For more information concerning treatment, please refer to the DES
fact sheet WD-WSEB-2-5 entitled, "Considerations
When Purchasing Water Treatment Equipment."
For additional information, please call the DES Water Supply Engineering
Bureau at 271-3139. We would appreciate your comment concerning this
fact sheet and your experiences relative to treatment of T/0. For an overall
listing of water supply related fact sheets, please request fact sheet
WD-WSEB-15-2. Drinking water fact sheets
are available through the DES web site at:
www.des.state.nh.us/wseb
then select: fact sheets. Please
check the internet annually for updates of this document. 11/00
|