|
Radon in New Hampshire by Eugene L. Boudette, N.H. State Geologist
INTRODUCTION
Radon is the 86th element in the chemical periodic table. Odorless,
colorless and chemically inert, it is a naturally occurring radioactive
noble gas that is found at varying levels everywhere in the environment.
Radon can only be sensed with instruments, specifically the Geiger
counter and, indirectly, with a scintillometer (gamma sensor). Because
the gas has a high density, it does not mix well with the Earth's atmosphere.
Thus, it tends to be concentrated in low places in the natural environment,
including valley floors or topographic depressions and in basements in
the built environment.
Radon is appreciably soluble in water, inversely proportional
to the water temperature. This relationship has important repercussions
which allow, for example, radon to be easily degassed into the built environment
from a combination of heating and aeration of the groundwater in the bathroom
shower.
Radon is especially mobile in groundwater, moving in response
to the gravity gradient within saturated fractured bedrock and surficial
deposits. The gas is also mobile in air within the fracture network of
the bedrock and the pore space of the surficial deposits. Here, it moves
by a combination of flow and diffusion, and is sometimes called "soil gas"
in levels near the surface of the earth. In some cases, radon in groundwater
can be exchanged into the air in soil and fractured rock by evaporation.
Radon-bearing air is also capable of migrating directly into an unsealed
built environment, especially basements.
HEALTH RISK
The health risk from radon was not generally accepted until the
1960s when a statistical study of the incidence of lung cancer among uranium
miners was done. Actually, an intuitive correlation of lung disease affecting
miners was made as early as 1500, but it was not suspected to be radon-related
carcinoma until the 1930s. No statistically-based studies of non-miners
and radon have been made to date. Thus, the environmental risks of radon
exposure to the average citizen cannot presently be established with confidence.
Nonetheless, advisory standards for radon in air have been established,
and standards for radon in water are under development.
Radon risk was not of universal concern to the public until 1984
when a worker at a nuclear generating facility in Pennsylvania triggered
a personal radiation exposure alarm when he entered, not left, the plant.
Investigation showed that his anomalous exposure was caused by excessive
radon in his house. The story was featured by the New York Times,
and the age of radon awareness began.
NATURAL RADIATION
Everyone on earth is subject to some degree of natural radiation
(part of which comes from radon), commonly called "background." This background
is mostly contributed from the rocks and surficial deposits or objects
made from them. Cosmic rays also contribute radiation from outer space,
and normal radioactive elements in the food chain add their component to
complete this natural exposure. Further, since the nuclear age began, an
additional contribution of radiation to the environment has been made from
military hardware and reactor accidents.
Natural radiation is not considered to be a health hazard because
the level of exposure is relatively low, and man has seemingly evolved
successfully in harmony with it.
THE PHYSICS OF RADIATION
There are more than 100 chemical elements each consisting of several
isotopes. The isotopes of any given element have the same number of protons,
but different numbers of neutrons. The neutrons have mass, hence the isotopes
come with different atomic weights. Some isotopes are unstable, and hence
radioactive. This instability is called radioactive decay which lowers
the atomic weight, forms a new isotope and a corresponding yield of nuclear
energy. The form of this energy determines its radiation type and, in part,
the destructive risk.
There are three unique types of radiation associated with radioactive
decay (Table 1): alpha, beta, and
gamma. Alpha radiation
has mass, a relatively large radius, a positive (+2) charge, and is composed
of two protons and two neutrons which move with a velocity of kilometers
per second. Beta radiation is simply composed of high energy electrons,
normally with a negative (-) charge. Beta is composed of nuclear electrons
and has less mass than alpha, but these electrons have greater velocity.
Gamma radiation is electromagnetic, has no mass, and travels at the speed
of light. Considering the characters of mass and velocity of radiation,
gamma has the greatest penetrating power and alpha the least. Alpha can,
in fact, be arrested with a sheet of bond paper, but it is the most dangerous
form of nuclear radiation for the damage it can do when colliding with
living tissue. Gamma radiation is comparable to x-rays and is the least
dangerous form of nuclear radiation in relatively low flux.
Table 1
NUCLEAR RADIATION
|
Type
|
Charge
|
Composition
|
Velocity
|
Energy
|
| Alpha() |
+
|
2 protons + 2 Neutrons
(=nuclei of helium atom)
|
Thousands of
km/sec
|
Maximum
(< 12 Mev)
|
| Beta() |
-
(+ in rare cases)
|
Nucleas electrons
|
|
Intermediate
(< 4 mev)
|
|
Gamma()
|
(none)
|
Electromagnetic energy like
X-rays, but of much shorter
wave length (no mass)
|
C
|
Minimum
(< 2 Mev)
|
|
C = velocity of light = 299,776 km/sec = 186,272 mil/sec
|
URANIUM AND HER DAUGHTERS
There are three isotopes of radon in nature, but only the isotope
with an atomic weight of 222 (222Rn) is abundant enough to be
of environmental importance. 222Rn is the product of the radioactive
decay of radium (226Ra) which is in the uranium (238U)
decay chain. For purposes of simplicity, only the 238U decay
chain is considered. In this arrangement uranium is the "parent" element
and the lighter isotopes below are called the "daughter" products. Here
we see a fundamental relationship: the abundance of radon in any given
geologic domain is a function of uranium distribution. Radon ultimately
comes from uranium dispersed in the rocks and surficial deposits around
us. Thus, radon potential is controlled by the geology, specifically the
distribution and geochemistry of uranium. Granite and metamorphic rocks
are among the rocks of the earth's crust that can be especially endowed
with uranium. New Hampshire is underlain by nearly equal amounts of these
rocks, thus radon is of critical concern here.
Radioactive isotopes are unstable and decay at specific measurable
variable rates. It is a mathematical convenience, therefore, to express
these rates of decay in terms of "half-life," or the time it takes for
one-half of a given amount to decay to the next "lower" isotope or a stable
isotope (fig. 1 and fig. 2). Note that radon has a half-life of only 3.8
days, in contrast to uranium which has a 4.51 billion year half-life. Radon's
relatively short half-life has important epidemiological consequences especially
when considering the daughter products that follow from radon decay.
|
Element
|
Mass
number
|
Atomic
number
|
Half - Life
|
Radiation
|
|
U
|
238
|
92
|
4.5 X 101 years |
a |
|
Th
|
234
|
90
|
24 days |
B |
|
Pa
|
234
|
91
|
6.7 hr, 1.2 min (2 isomers) |
B |
|
U
|
234
|
92
|
2.5 X 105 years |
a |
|
Th
|
230
|
90
|
8 X 104 |
a |
|
Ra
|
226
|
88
|
1,620 years |
a |
|
Ra
|
222
|
86
|
3.8 days |
 |
|
218
|
84
|
3 min |
99.97% , 0.03% B |
|
214
|
82
|
26.8 min. |
 |
|
or At
|
218
|
85
|
2 sec. |
a |
|
214
|
83
|
20 min. |
99.6% , 0.04% a |
|
214
|
84
|
1.6 X 10-4 sec. |
 |
|
or Ti
|
210
|
81
|
1.3 min. |
B |
|
Pb
|
210
|
82
|
22 years |
 |
|
Bi
|
210
|
83
|
5 days |
B |
|
Po
|
210
|
84
|
138 days |
 |
|
Pb
|
206
|
82
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
8a + 6B
|
|
Figure 1. The Uranium -238 Natural Radioactive Series |
Figure 2.(not shown)
The uranium-238 decay series showing the half-lives of elements
and their modes of decay.
There are a number of ways to express the measurement of radiation, but
the Curie Standard (named for French physicist Marie Curie) has been adapted
as a matter of convenience for radon. A curie is the amount of radiation
emitted from one gram of 226Ra. This is relatively a lot of
radiation, and the use of the pico-Curie per liter (pCi/L) is the most
convenient measure. One pCi is one trillionth of a curie (10-12).
Thus, the concentration of radon can be expressed in terms of either a
liter of air or water.
RADON TRANSPORT
Health risk concerns about radon require separate approaches for
radon in air, which is inhaled into the lungs, and radon in water, which
is mostly ingested into the digestive tract. Though there is a danger of
cell damage from the powerful alpha radiation energy produced from the
decay of radon, a far greater risk comes from the radiation emitted by
radon's daughters which can reside within the body because they are compatible
with human biochemistry. Radon-rich water arrives with human biochemistry.
Radon-rich water arrives with a considerable population of its daughter
products because of the short half-life of the isotope. Radon levels in
outdoor air, indoor air, air in fractured rocks and surficial deposits,
surface water, and groundwater can be quite different (fig. 3).
Fig. 3(not shown) Radon Levels in Air and Water
GEOLOGY OF RADON
It has been observed that radon production is ultimately linked
to the natural distribution of uranium in the earth's crust. All rocks
contain measurable amounts of uranium varying according to their geochemical
controls and genesis. Background amounts of uranium are less than 3 parts
per million (ppm) in most rocks and surficial deposits. Uranium content
in rocks can, however, vary greatly up to ore grade (>1,000 ppm). Surficial
deposits are derived from the process of mechanical and chemical weathering
of rocks, often with transport and redeposition by ice, water, or wind.
Most of these deposits also contain less than 3 ppm uranium. Residual soils
and closely redeposited weathering products of rocks, thus, tend to mimic
the uranium content of the rocks that they came from if chemical weathering
has not been profound. This is especially true of some glacial tills which
are abundant in New Hampshire.
Some rocks frequently have an above-average uranium content, including
specialized granite, light-colored volcanic rocks, carbonaceous shales,
and metamorphic rock. We have observed that New Hampshire is underlain
almost entirely be granitic and metamorphic rocks. Interestingly, many
of the metamorphic rocks were deposited as light colored volcanics, such
as rhyolite, and black carbonaceous sediments. Thus, many rocks of the
state present a high potential for uranium. Fortunately, most of the granite
in the state is of a type that is known to have a low to moderate uranium
content (<5 ppm). One variety of red to pink granite in the White Mountains,
Conway Granite, is among the most uranium-rich known in the world (averaging
about 25 ppm). This particular rock, however contains abundant weathering-resistant
accessory minerals, such as zircon, which effectively lock-up the uranium
(and most of the radon) making the rocks less dangerous than they could
be.
A unique type of granite, called "two-mica granite," and related
pegmatite is abundant in the southeastern, central, and western parts of
the state. This rock is characterized by moderate amounts of uranium (about
5 to 10 ppm), but it contains only minor amounts of resistate accessory
minerals. Thus, the uranium is quite mobile (labile) in weathering processes
in these rocks, and is capable of being dissolved and redeposited into
local concentrations, sometimes exceeding ore-grade, creating sources of
radon.
A unique type of uranium deposit that is found in peat has recently
been discovered in New Hampshire as well as in other states. Some of these
deposits can contain as much as 1 percent uranium. This uranium is young,"
however, fractionated away from its daughters. As such, it is not notably
radioactive because of the long half-life of uranium, and it is not associated
with significant radon. It can, however, present a risk as a toxic metal.
Faults, fractures, fissures, and especially the shatter zones
which cut the rocks, can be important conduits for radon migration. Some
of these features have been identified in New Hampshire where the structures
are venting radon either from groundwater found along them or uranium deposits
that have formed there. Glacial till that is comprised of material from
uranium-rich rocks and transported by ice movement can also present a radon
source over rocks not other wise enriched in uranium. Thus, in areas with
faults, shatter zones, and glacial tills, there is not always a direct
correlation between rocks and radon.
RADON RISK MAPS
As noted, the distribution of uranium in the bedrock is dependent
on a combination of the genesis, geochemistry, and mineral content of a
rock unit. Fractionation of uranium into surficial deposits is dependent
on variables such as weathering processes, transport, and redesposition
sedimentation of bedrock products. In order to assess radon potential,
knowledge of the character and distribution of rock types and surficial
deposits must be known. Such information is furnished by geologic maps
of different types (fig. 4). These geologic maps can also be augmented
by radioactivity maps that portray directly measured values made either
on the ground or from the air (fig. 5). From these types of maps, derivative
maps can then be created that show radon potential for estimating human
risk. The ultimate map is obviously one complied from direct ground emanation
of radon measured with special instruments that, quite literally, "sniff"
radon. These maps compiled at scales fo 1:24,000 (1" equals about 0.4 mil)
and larger have engineering importance and can be useful in deciding upon
the suitability of land for development. Such maps, however, would be of
limited use in forecasting radon levels in water wells drilled into the
bedrock.
Fig. 4(not shown) Generalized Geologic Map of New Hampshire
Fig. 5(not shown) Aerial Radiometric Map of New Hampshire
RADON IN THE ENVIRONMENT
Outdoor Air. Radon in outdoor air poses no risk to human
health. The range in concentration varies from 0.1 pCi/L to 30 pCi/L, averaging
about 0.2 pCi/L. Higher, but not dangerous, concentrations are possible
during passive weather conditions along the floors of sharp topographic
depressions that signal faults and shatter zones. No deep mines are operated
in New Hampshire, and quarries operated for stone and aggregate production
are probably sufficiently ventilated by nature to present no radon risk.
Surficial Deposits. Air (soil air) in water-unsaturated
surficial deposits including glacial sediments has much more variable concentrations
and higher levels of radon than free air. These levels vary from about
100 pCi/L to more than 100,000 pCi/L, but probably average between 200
and 2,000 pCi/L near the surface. The radon in these surficial deposits
is mainly attributable to the decay of radium. Soil gas radon can come
from groundwater evaporating or "pumping" within the surficial deposits,
especially during periods when the water table is rising and falling. Once
mobile in the soil, the radon is free to respond to the controls of the
diffusion gradient (migration from a higher to a lower concentration)
and flow (pressure) gradient.
Surface Water. Radon in surface water is free to rapidly
enter the atmosphere, and thus seldom exceeds levels of about 100 pCi/L.
Certainly, public surface water supplies do not pose a radon risk. Moreover,
these waters are required to be tested for radioactivity. Some springs
in New Hampshire, especially in the western part of the state, are known
from ground radiation measurements to carry appreciable amounts of radon.
Testing them for radon is recommended, especially where spring waters are
emanating from known faults, fissures in two-mica granite, and either rocks
or surficial deposits, especially within the White Mountains.
Groundwater. Groundwater is obtained in New Hampshire from
surficial deposits (dug wells and screened wells) and from bedrock sources
(drilled wells). The water in surficial deposits is contained in pore space,
and the water in rock-drilled wells is contained principally in fractures
(secondary porosity).
The crystalline rocks of the state do not have appreciable primary
porosity. The radon levels in New Hampshire groundwater vary as much as
six orders of magnitude ranging from about 100 pCi/L to as much as 4 million
pCi/L! The groundwaters of primary porosity in surficial deposits carry
much lower radon levels than those of secondary porosity in bedrock. The
radon level range of groundwater of primary porosity is not established
with any confidence, but is probably less than 40,000 pCi/L in most wells.
There is a general consensus among specialists working in radon
that 10,000 to 20,000 pCi/L of radon in groundwater is cause for concern
and 100,000 pCi/L requires remedial action. Levels of radon approaching
100,000 pCi/L in water supplies are capable of being the principal contributors
to excessive radon levels in the built environment simply by degassing
during water use.
Research into the geology of radon has not progressed to the point
where the radon potential of a proposed well in bedrock can be predicted.
We know that parameters such as (1) well depth, (2) depth of water production,
(3) water yield, (4) pumping rate (stress), and (5) proximity of other
wells play important roles. Studies in New Hampshire have not, to date,
produced any consistent pattern. It appears, in fact, that drilled wells
each have individual personalities. The only consistent relationship appears
to be related to rock type. Thus, well planning, including a concern for
radon, begins with the interpretation of a geologic map. The evolving technology
of drilling into bedrock to exploit the groundwater resource opens questions
about artificially accelerating the mobility of radon by pumping stress.
It is reasonable to believe that stressing an aquifer increases groundwater
mobility rates far beyond those predicted by nature. Such accelerated rates
could result in "sweeping" a much larger volume of rocks for its groundwater
and enhancing both radon concentration and mobility.
A corollary to this observation raises another interesting question.
How do radon levels of well water immediately after drilling compare to
radon levels after sustained use? Some rock wells in New Hampshire have,
indeed, shown a steady build-up of radon with service, but others have
shown fluctuating radon levels with time and season. Further, the dynamics
of bedrock aquifer recharge also has much to do with radon level.
It becomes obvious that no two aquifers are alike and, therefore,
no consistent set of variables govern the potential for radon in the groundwater.
Habitat and Workplace. Ancestral man unwittingly placed
himself at risk with radon when he took up residence in certain caves and
used water from radon-enriched springs. The course of human history has
been, therefore, one of coexistence with the isotope, but obviously with
ever-increasing exposure. As technology advanced, man learned to enjoy
the comforts of enclosed architecture which eventually brought conveniences
such as central heating. In short, the evolution of architecture and equipment
brought about the opportunity for radon to concentrate in the built environment,
especially in climates marked by a distinct winter season.
Cold weather results in reducing ventilation and creating a pressure
differential between the colder atmosphere and the heated structure. Such
a differential results in the structure acting as "vacuum cleaner" for
radon-slaked soil gas if basement floors and foundations are not sealed.
If there is an important amount of radon in the water supply, aeration
by equipment such as showers and washing machines add this radon to that
already there. Air conditioning of structures diminishes the ventilation,
but the pressure differential is reversed. Structures without air conditioning
are ventilated to the atmosphere and reduce the radon risk in the warmer
months.
Meaningful statistics for radon levels in New Hampshire structures
exist only for indoor air in homes. A study completed by the N.H. Division
of Public Health Services on a random selection of 1,810 homes between
1988 and 1990 found that the average was 4.8 pCi/L and that 27.8 percent
of the homes recorded levels in excess of 4 pCi/L. One home was measured
at 479 pCi/L.
Interim hazard levels of 4 pCi/L in air and 40,000 pCi/L in water
have been used in advisory context. As a first approximation, 40,000 pCi/L
in the water supply of a home results in 4 pCi/L in the household air.
Almost 7,000 public and private water supplies in New Hampshire have been
tested for radon levels (Table 2). More than 16 percent of these supplies
exceed 10,000 pCi/L which is probably a level that can make a measurable,
but not dangerous, contribution to the radon within structures. About 18
percent of New Hampshire homes and some commercial buildings are dependent
upon private unregulated water supplies obtained from wells drilled into
bedrock. Radon testing to date in this class of water supply indicates
that 5 to 10 percent of the well waters exceed 40,000 pCi/L. It has been
noted that such waters can make a potentially unhealthful contribution
of radon to the indoor air. The amount of this contribution, however, depends
on variables, especially the volume of air and the volume of water used
during a specified period of time.
Table 2.
Radon Analysis in New Hampshire Water Supplies (data from
DES laboratories for a sample group from 1/1/84 through 12/31/92).
|
Radon - 222 (pCi/L.)
|
Community
|
Non-community
|
Private
|
| 0 - 300 |
|
|
|
| 301 - 10,000 |
|
|
|
| 10,001 - 40,000 |
|
|
|
| Greater than 40,000 |
|
|
|
| Totals |
|
|
|
|
pCi/L
|
Total
|
|
|
Grand Total 6981
|
0 - 300
|
826
|
11.8%
|
|
301 - 10,000
|
4765
|
68.3
|
|
10,001 - 40,000
|
1140
|
16.3
|
|
> 40,000
|
250
|
3.6
|
RECOMMENDED HUMAN RESPONSE
Once "excessive" levels of radon are delivered "free of charge"
by geology, mitigation becomes a problem for engineers and health specialists.
In cases where groundwater is not the major contributor of radon into a
structure, a combination of ventilation and sealing is indicated to prevent
radon build-up and recharge. The elimination of excessive radon in water
is also possible through the use of engineered devices that aerate the
radon into the atmosphere. The daughter products of radon that the water
also carries can be stripped and captured by adsorption or chemical exchange-processing
systems such as activated charcoal filters. The use of such systems,
however, requires a commitment to the safe disposal of cartridges or liquids
that become dangerously radioactive.
Pioneering work has been done by the Environmental Research Group
at the University of New Hampshire in safely reducing the levels of radon
and its decay products from water supplies. The U.S. Environmental Protection
Agency maintains a register of commercial specialists approved to do radon
mitigation in indoor air and water. The use of only approved practitioners
is strongly advised.
It is recommended that all residents of New Hampshire test their
dwellings for indoor air radon levels. Also, homes and commercial buildings
supplied from wells drilled into bedrock should test their water supplies.
Ideally, water in newly drilled wells should be tested both before sustained
use and then several months to a year later. If the radon level has increased
significantly on the second test, yearly periodic tests should be done
until the radon level stabilizes. Water tests can be done by either EPA-certified
commercial testing laboratories or by the state analytical chemistry laboratory
operated by DES in Concord. New Hampshire residents are showing an increasing
commitment not only informing themselves about radon risk, but also assuring
themselves that radon levels in their indoor air and water supplies are
at "safe" levels.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION
Questions on radon mitigation and health risk should be directed
to Bureau of Radiological Health Services, Health and Welfare Building,
29 Hazen Drive, Concord, NH 03301, (603) 271-4674 or 1-800-852-3345 x-4674.
SUGGESTIONS FOR ADDITIONAL READING
Boudette, E.L., 1990, The Geology of New Hampshire:
Rocks & Minerals, V. 65, No. 4, p. 306-312.
Cothern, C.R. and Smith, J.E., Jr., eds. 1987, Environmental
Radon: New York, Pleuum Publishing Corp. 378 p.
Gundersen, L.C.S. and Schumann, R.S., (1993), Geologic Radon
Potential of EPA Region I: US Geological Survey, Open File Report 93-292A,
245.
Hall, F.R., Boudette, E.L., and Olsewski, W.J., Jr., 1987, Geologic
Controls and Radon Occurrence in New England, in Graves B. (Ed.), Radon,
Radium, and Other Radioactivity in Groundwater: Chelsea, MI, Lewis
Publishers, p. 15-30.
Kinner, N.E., Malley, J.P., Clement, J.A., Quern, P.A., and Schell,
G.S., 1990, Radon Removal Techniques for Small Community Public Water
Supplies: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Research and Development
Project Summary, EPA/600/sz-90/047, 6 p.
Kinner, N.E., Malley, J.P., Jr., and Clement, J.A., 1990, Radon
Removal Using Point-of-Entry Water Treatment Techniques: U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency, Research and Development Project Summary, EPA/600/sz-90/047,
6 p.
Pirie, J.C. and Hannington, J.E., 1989, New Hampshire Radon
Survey 1987-1988 (with Addendum: New Hampshire Radon Survey 1987-1990):
N.H. Division of Public Health Services, Report #89-015.
Nazaroff, W.W. and Nero, L.V., Jr., eds., 1988, Radon and Its
Decay Products in Indoor Air: New York, John Wiley and Sons, Inc.,
518 p.
Otton, J.K., 1992, The Geology of Radon: U.S. Geological
Survey, General Interest Publication, 29 p.
|